Unit Testing with Golang

Continue from the previous topic

Unit Testing is a level of automated software testing that units which can be modular parts of the program are tested. Normally, the “unit” refers to a function, but it doesn’t necessary always be so. A unit typically takes in data and returns an output. Correspondingly, a unit test case passes data into the unit and check the resultant output to see if they meet the expectations.

Unit Testing Files

In Golang, unit test cases are written in <module>_test.go files, grouped according to their functionality. In our case, when we do unit testing for the videos web services, we will have the unit test cases written in video_test.go. Also, the test files need to be in the same package as tested functions.

Necessary Packages

In the beginning, we need to import the “testing” package. In each of our unit test function, we will take in a parameter t which is a pointer to testing.T struct. It is the main struct that we will be using to call out any failure or error.

In our code video_test.go, we use only the function Error in testing.T to log the errors and to mark the test function fails. In fact, Error function is a convenient function in the package that combines calling of Log function and then the Fail function. The Fail function marks the test case has failed but it still allows the execution of the rest of the test case. There is another similar function called FailNow. The FailNow function is stricter and exits the test case once it’s encountered. So, if FailNow function is what you need, you have to call the Fatal function which is another convenient function that combines Log and FailNow instead of the Error function.

Besides the “testing” package, there is another package that we need in order to do unit testing for Golang web applications. It is the “net/http/httptest” package. It allows us to use the client functions of the “net/http” package to send an HTTP request and capturing the HTTP response.

Test Doubles, Mock, and Dependency Injection

Before proceeding to writing unit test functions, we need to get ready with Test Doubles. Test Double is a generic term for any case where we replace a production object for testing purposes. There are several different types of Test Double, of which a Mock is one. Using Test Doubles helps making the unit test cases more independent.

In video_test.go, we apply the Dependency Injection in the design of Test Doubles. Dependency Injection is a design pattern that decouples the layer dependencies in our program. This is done through passing a dependency to the called object, structure, or function. This dependency is used to perform the action instead of the object, structure, or function.

Currently, the handleVideoRequests handler function uses a global sql.DB struct to open a database connection to our PostgreSQL database to perform the CRUD. For unit testing, we should not depend on database connection so much and thus the dependency on sql.DB should be removed. The dependency on sql.DB then should be injected into the process flow from the main program.

To do so, firstly, we need to introduce a new interface called IVideo.

type IVideo interface {

GetVideo(userID string, id int) (err error)
GetAllVideos(userID string) (videos []Video, err error)
CreateVideo(userID string) (err error)
UpdateVideo(userID string) (err error)
DeleteVideo() (err error)

}

Secondly, we make our Video struct to implement the new interface and let one of the fields in the Video struct a pointer to sql.DB. Unlike in C#, we have to specify which interface the class is implementing, in Golang, as long as the Video struct implements all the methods that IVideo has (which is already does), then Video struct is implementing the IVideo interface. So now our Video struct looks as following.

type Video struct {
Db *sql.DB
ID int `json:"id"`
Name string `json:"videoTitle"`
URL string `json:"url"`
YoutubeVideoID string `json:"youtubeVideoId"`
}

As you can see, we added a new field called Db which is a pointer to sql.DB.

Now, we can create a Test Double called FakeVideo which implements IVideo interface to be used in unit testing.

// FakeVideo is a record of favourite video for unit test
type FakeVideo struct {
ID int `json:"id"`
Name string `json:"videoTitle"`
URL string `json:"url"`
YoutubeVideoID string `json:"youtubeVideoId"`
CreatedBy string `json:"createdBy"`
}


// GetVideo returns one single video record based on id
func (video *FakeVideo) GetVideo(userID string, id int) (err error) {
jsonFile, err := os.Open("testdata/fake_videos.json")
if err != nil {
return
}

defer jsonFile.Close()

jsonData, err := ioutil.ReadAll(jsonFile)
if err != nil {
return
}

var fakeVideos []FakeVideo
json.Unmarshal(jsonData, &fakeVideos)

for _, fakeVideo := range fakeVideos {
if fakeVideo.ID == id && fakeVideo.CreatedBy == userID {
video.ID = fakeVideo.ID
video.Name = fakeVideo.Name
video.URL = fakeVideo.URL
video.YoutubeVideoID = fakeVideo.YoutubeVideoID

return
}
}

err = errors.New("no corresponding video found")

return
}
...

So instead of reading the info from the PostgreSQL database, we read mock data from a JSON file which is stored in testdata folder. The testdata folder is a special folder where Golang will ignores when it builds the project. Hence, with this folder, we can easily read our test data from JSON file fake_videos.json through relative path from video_test.go.

Since now the Video struct is updated, we need to update our handleVideoAPIRequests method to be as follows.

func handleVideoAPIRequests(video models.IVideo) http.HandlerFunc {
    return func(writer http.ResponseWriter, request *http.Request) {
        var err error

       ...

        switch request.Method {
        case "GET":
            err = handleVideoAPIGet(writer, request, video, user)
        case "POST":
            err = handleVideoAPIPost(writer, request, video, user)
        case "PUT":
            err = handleVideoAPIPut(writer, request, video, user)
        case "DELETE":
            err = handleVideoAPIDelete(writer, request, video, user)
        }

        if err != nil {
            util.CheckError(err)
            return
        }
    }
}

So now we pass an instance of the Video struct directly into the handleVideoAPIRequests. The various Video methods will use the sql.DB that is a field in the struct instead. At this point of time, handleVideoAPIRequests no longer follows the ServeHTTP method signature and is no longer a handler function.

Thus, in the main function, instead of attaching a handler function to the URL, we call the handleVideoAPIRequests function as follows.

func main() {
...

mux.HandleFunc("/api/video/",
handleRequestWithLog(handleVideoAPIRequests(&models.Video{Db: db})))

...
}

Writing Unit Test Cases for Web Services

Now we are good to write unit test cases in video_test.go. Instead of passing a Video struct like in server.go, this time we pass in the FakeVideo struct, as highlighted in one of the test cases below.

func TestHandleGetAllVideos(t *testing.T) {
    mux = http.NewServeMux()
    mux.HandleFunc("/api/video/", handleVideoAPIRequests(&models.FakeVideo{}))
    writer = httptest.NewRecorder()

    request, _ := http.NewRequest("GET", "/api/video/", nil)
    mux.ServeHTTP(writer, request)

   if writer.Code != 200 {
        t.Errorf("Response code is %v", writer.Code)
    }

    var videos []models.Video
    json.Unmarshal(writer.Body.Bytes(), &videos)

    if len(videos) != 2 {
        t.Errorf("The list of videos is retrieved wrongly")
    }
}

By doing this, instead of fetching videos from the PostgreSQL database, now it will get from the fake_videos.json in testdata.

Testing with Mock User Info

Now, since we have implemented user authentication, how do we make it works in unit testing also. To do so, in auth.go, we introduce a flag called isTesting which is false as follows.

// This flag is for the use of unit testing to do fake login
var isTesting bool

Then in the TestMain function, which is provided in testing package to do setup or teardown, we will set this to be true.

So how do we use this information? In auth.go, there is this function profileFromSession which retrieves the Google user information stored in the session. For unit testing, we won’t have this kind of user information. Hence, we need to mock this data too as shown below.

if isTesting {
        return &Profile{
            ID: "154226945598527500122",
            DisplayName: "Chun Lin",
            ImageURL: "https://avatars1.githubusercontent.com/u/8535306?s=460&v=4",
        }
    }

With this, then we can test whether the functions, for example, are retrieving correct videos of the specified user.

Running Unit Test Locally and on Azure DevOps

Finally, to run the test cases, we simply use the command below.

go test -v

Alternatively, Visual Studio Code allows us to run specified test case by clicking on the “Run Test” link above the test case.

Running test on VS Code.

We can then continue to add the testing as one of the steps in Azure DevOps Build pipeline, as shown below.

Added the go test task in Azure DevOps Build pipeline.

By doing this, if any of the test cases fails, there won’t be a build made and thus our system becomes more stable now.

RESTful Web Service in Golang and Front-end Served with VueJS

Continue from the previous topic

There is one behaviour in our Golang web application that will frustrate our users. Everytime we add, update, or delete a video record, the web page gets refreshed. So if at that time there is a video being played, then poof, it’s gone after you add, update, or delete a record. That’s a bad UX.

To overcome there, I decide to implement RESTful web services in the Golang project and the frontend will use VueJS library to update the web page.

Firstly, we need to wrap a web service interface over the CRUD functions we have in our web application. JSON will be used as the data transport format. To do that, we will introduce a new handler function to multiplex request to the correct function in our RESTful web service.

func handleVideoAPIRequests(video models.IVideo) http.HandlerFunc {
return func(writer http.ResponseWriter, request *http.Request) {

var err error
switch request.Method {
case "GET":
err = handleVideoAPIGet(writer, request, video)

case "POST":
err = handleVideoAPIPost(writer, request, video)

case "PUT":
err = handleVideoAPIPut(writer, request, video)

case "DELETE":
err = handleVideoAPIDelete(writer, request, video)
}

if err != nil {
util.CheckError(err)

return
}

}
}

HTTP GET

Then for each of the HTTP methods, we will process the request independently. For example, to retrieve the list of videos or one of the videos, we will use GET method, i.e. handleVideoAPIGet().

The list of video records at the right are retrieved using HTTP GET.
func handleVideoAPIGet(writer http.ResponseWriter, request *http.Request, video models.IVideo) (err error) {

videoIDURL := path.Base(request.URL.Path)

var output []byte

if videoIDURL == "video" {
videos, errIf := video.GetAllVideos()
err = errIf
util.CheckError(errIf)

output, errIf = json.MarshalIndent(&videos, "", "\t")
err = errIf
util.CheckError(errIf)

writer.Header().Set("Content-Type", "application/json")
writer.Write(output)

return
}

videoID, err := strconv.Atoi(videoIDURL)

if err != nil {
util.CheckError(err)
return
}

err = video.GetVideo(videoID)
util.CheckError(err)

output, err = json.MarshalIndent(&video, "", "\t")
util.CheckError(err)

writer.Header().Set("Content-Type", "application/json")
writer.Write(output)

return
}

This method seems long but in the first half of the function, it is checking if the URL ends with /video or it ends with a number. If it ends with /video, that means it is not asking for a specific video but it’s asking for all valid videos. Thus video.GetAllVideos() is called and the videos are returned as JSON array.

So what if it’s only requesting for particular video with video ID? There is where the second half of the function comes in. It will first convert the part of the URL into an integer using strconv.Atoi(). Then we will retrieve the video based on that integer as video ID and then return it as a JSON object.

HTTP POST

To create a new video record in database, the system will call the handleVideoAPIPost().

func handleVideoAPIPost(writer http.ResponseWriter, request *http.Request, video models.IVideo) (err error) {

length := request.ContentLength
body := make([]byte, length)
request.Body.Read(body)
json.Unmarshal(body, &video)

err = video.CreateVideo()
if err != nil {
util.CheckError(err)
apiStatus := models.APIStatus{
Status: false,
Message: err.Error(),
}

output, err := json.MarshalIndent(&apiStatus, "", "\t")
util.CheckError(err)

writer.WriteHeader(400)
writer.Header().Set("Content-Type", "application/json")

writer.Write(output)
} else {
apiStatus := models.APIStatus{
Status: true,
Message: "A video is successfully added to the database.",
}

output, err := json.MarshalIndent(&apiStatus, "", "\t")
util.CheckError(err)

writer.WriteHeader(200)
writer.Header().Set("Content-Type", "application/json")
writer.Write(output)
}

return
}

The beginning of the function for POST method is reading from body is because we will post a JSON object containing the new video record information to it. So it needs to retrieve the JSON object from the body.

Another interesting thing in this function is that it will return JSON object indicating whether the action of adding new record is successful or not with a corresponding HTTP status code of 400 or 200. Doing so is to let the frontend feedback to the user so that the user knows whether the record is successfully inserted to the database or not.

HTTP PUT

How about if we want to update existing video record? Well, we can rely on the PUT method. The PUT method requires us to tell it which resource it will update. Hence the function handleVideoAPIPut() is as follows.

func handleVideoAPIPut(writer http.ResponseWriter, request *http.Request, video models.IVideo) (err error) {

videoIDURL := path.Base(request.URL.Path)
videoID, err := strconv.Atoi(videoIDURL)
if err != nil {
util.CheckError(err)
return
}

err = video.GetVideo(videoID)
if err != nil {
util.CheckError(err)
apiStatus := models.APIStatus{
Status: false,
Message: err.Error(),
}

output, err := json.MarshalIndent(&apiStatus, "", "\t")
util.CheckError(err)

writer.WriteHeader(400)
writer.Header().Set("Content-Type", "application/json")
writer.Write(output)
}

length := request.ContentLength
body := make([]byte, length)
request.Body.Read(body)
json.Unmarshal(body, &video)

err = video.UpdateVideo()
if err != nil {
util.CheckError(err)
apiStatus := models.APIStatus{
Status: false,
Message: err.Error(),
}

output, err := json.MarshalIndent(&apiStatus, "", "\t")
util.CheckError(err)

writer.WriteHeader(400)
writer.Header().Set("Content-Type", "application/json")
writer.Write(output)
} else {
apiStatus := models.APIStatus{
Status: true,
Message: "A video record is successfully updated.",
}

output, err := json.MarshalIndent(&apiStatus, "", "\t")
util.CheckError(err)

writer.WriteHeader(200)
writer.Header().Set("Content-Type", "application/json")
writer.Write(output)
}

return
}

Similar to how we have done in handleVideoAPIGet(), we first need to get the video ID from the URL with the help of strconv.Atoi(). Then we will check whether there is an existing video in the database with the video ID. If there is none, then we simply return JSON object updating frontend with an error message. If there is video found with the video ID, we will then proceed to update it with the info from the JSON object passed via the request body.

There is one thing to take note here is that we are not replacing the existing video record entirely. We are only updating part of it. So the JSON object should contain only the fields needed to be updated.

Updating the video record.

HTTP DELETE

The function to handle DELETE method will be similar to the one handling PUT method.

func handleVideoAPIDelete(writer http.ResponseWriter, request *http.Request, video models.IVideo) (err error) {

   videoIDURL := path.Base(request.URL.Path)
    videoID, err := strconv.Atoi(videoIDURL)

    if err != nil {
        util.CheckError(err)
        return
    }

   err = video.GetVideo(videoID)
   if err != nil {
        util.CheckError(err)

        apiStatus := models.APIStatus{
            Status: false,
            Message: err.Error(),
        }
        output, err := json.MarshalIndent(&apiStatus, "", "\t")
        util.CheckError(err)

        writer.WriteHeader(400)
        writer.Header().Set("Content-Type", "application/json")
        writer.Write(output)

    }

    err = video.DeleteVideo()
    if err != nil {

        util.CheckError(err)

        apiStatus := models.APIStatus{
            Status: false,
            Message: err.Error(),
        }
        output, err := json.MarshalIndent(&apiStatus, "", "\t")
        util.CheckError(err)

        writer.WriteHeader(400)
        writer.Header().Set("Content-Type", "application/json")
        writer.Write(output)

    } else {

        apiStatus := models.APIStatus{
            Status: true,
            Message: "A video record is deleted.",
        }
        output, err := json.MarshalIndent(&apiStatus, "", "\t")
        util.CheckError(err)

        writer.WriteHeader(200)
        writer.Header().Set("Content-Type", "application/json")
        writer.Write(output)

    }

    return
}

Similar to how we have done in handleVideoAPIPut(), we first need to get the video ID from the URL with the help of strconv.Atoi(). Then we will check whether there is an existing video in the database with the video ID. If there is none, then we simply return JSON object updating frontend with an error message. If there is video found with the video ID, we will then proceed to delete it.

The popup to check if user really wants the video record to be removed from the list.

Frontend with VueJS

Now, let’s see how we use VueJS library to display the video list.

It is done with just a for loop to list down all the relevant videos and having values stored in data attributes for update and delete the video record.

References

Monitoring Golang Web App with Application Insights

Continue from the previous topic

Application Insights is available on Azure Portal as a way for developers to monitor their live web applications and to detect performance anomalies. It has a dashboard with charts to help developers diagnose issues and understand user behaviors on the applications. It works for apps written on multiple programming languages other than .NET too.

Setup of Application Insights on Azure

It is straightforward to setup Application Insights on Azure Portal. If we have already setup a default CI/CD for simple Golang web app, an Application Insights account will be created automatically.

Creating new Application Insights account. The golab002 is automatically created when we setup a new Golang DevOps project on Azure Portal.

Once the Application Insights account is created, we need to get its Instrument Key which is required before any telemetry can be sent via the SDK.

Simplicity in ASP .NET Core

In ASP .NET Core projects, we can easily include Application Insights by including the Nuget package Microsoft.ApplicationInsights.AspNetCore and adding the following highlighted code in Program.cs.

public static IWebHostBuilder CreateWebHostBuilder(string[] args) =>
WebHost.CreateDefaultBuilder(args)
.UseStartup()
.UseApplicationInsights();

Setup of Application Insights Telemetry in Golang

So, what if we want to monitor our Golang applications which are hosted on Azure App Service? Luckily, Microsoft officially published an Application Insights SDK for Golang which is also open sourced on GitHub.

Since June 2015, Luke Kim, the Principal Group Software Engineering Manger at Microsoft, and other Microsoft engineers have been working on this open source project.

Introducing Application Insights to Golang application is not as straightforward as doing the same in ASP .NET Core project described above. Here, I will cover only how to use Telemetry.

First of all, we need to download and install the relevant package with the following go get command.

go get github.com/Microsoft/ApplicationInsights-Go/appinsights

Tracing Errors

Previously, we already have a centralized checkError function to handle errors returned from different sources in our code. So, we will have the following code added in the function to send traces back to Application Insights when an error occurs.

func checkError(err error) {
    if err != nil {
        client := appinsights.NewTelemetryClient(os.Getenv("APPINSIGHTS_INSTRUMENTATIONKEY"))

        trace := appinsights.NewTraceTelemetry(err.Error(), appinsights.Error)
        trace.Timestamp = time.Now()

        client.Track(trace)

        panic(err)    
}
}

So, when there is an error on our application, we will receive a trace record as such on the Metrics of Application Insights as shown below.

An error is captured. In this case, it’s because wrong DB host is stated.

However, doing this way doesn’t give us details such as call stack. Hence, if we want to log an exception in our application, we need to use TrackPanic in the SDK as follows.

func checkError(err error) {
    if err != nil {
        client := appinsights.NewTelemetryClient(os.Getenv("APPINSIGHTS_INSTRUMENTATIONKEY"))

        trace := appinsights.NewTraceTelemetry(err.Error(), appinsights.Error)
        trace.Timestamp = time.Now()

        client.Track(trace)

        // false indicates that we should have this handle the panic, and
        // not re-throw it.
        defer appinsights.TrackPanic(client, false)

        panic(err)    
}
}

This will capture and report call stack of the panic and display it on Azure Portal. With this, we can easily see which exceptions are occurring and how often.

Traces and exceptions. The details of exception includes call stack.

Tracing Page Views

Besides errors, let’s capture the page views as well so that we can easily tell which handler function is called and how much time is spent in it. To do so, we introduce a new function called handleRequestWithLog.

func handleRequestWithLog(h func(http.ResponseWriter, *http.Request)) http.HandlerFunc {

    return http.HandlerFunc(func(writer http.ResponseWriter, request *http.Request) {

        startTime := time.Now()
        h(writer, request)
        duration := time.Now().Sub(startTime)

        client := appinsights.NewTelemetryClient(
os.Getenv("APPINSIGHTS_INSTRUMENTATIONKEY"))

        trace := appinsights.NewRequestTelemetry(
request.Method, request.URL.Path, duration, "200")
        trace.Timestamp = time.Now()

        client.Track(trace)
    })
}

Then we can modify our server.go to be as follows.

mux.HandleFunc("/", handleRequestWithLog(index))
mux.HandleFunc("/addVideo", handleRequestWithLog(addVideo))
mux.HandleFunc("/updateVideo", handleRequestWithLog(updateVideo))
mux.HandleFunc("/deleteVideo", handleRequestWithLog(deleteVideo))

Now whenever we visit a page or perform an action, the behaviour will be logged on Application Insights, as shown in the following screenshot. As you can see, the server response time is logged too.

Adding new video, deleting video, and viewing homepage actions.

With these records, the Performance chart in Application Insights will be plotted too.

Monitoring the performance of our Golang web application.

Tracing Static File Downloads

Besides the web pages, we are also interested at static files, such as understanding how fast the server responses when the static file is retrieved.

To do so, we first need to introduce a new handler function called staticFile.go.

package main

import (
    "mime"
    "net/http"
    "strings"
)

func staticFile(writer http.ResponseWriter, request *http.Request) {
    urlComponents := strings.Split(request.URL.Path, "/")

    http.ServeFile(
writer, request, "public/"+urlComponents[len(urlComponents)-1])

    fileComponents := strings.Split(
urlComponents[len(urlComponents)-1], ".")
    fileExtension := fileComponents[len(fileComponents)-1]

    writer.Header().Set(
"Content-Type", mime.TypeByExtension(fileExtension))
}

The reason why we need do as such is because we want to apply the handleRequestWithLog function for static files in server.go too.

mux.HandleFunc("/static/", handleRequestWithLog(staticFile))

By doing so, we will start to see the following on Search of Application Insights.

A list of downloaded CSS and JS static files and their corresponding server response time.

Conclusion

In ASP .NET Core applications, we normally need add the UseApplicationInsights as shown below in Program.cs then all the server actions will be automatically traced. However, this is not the case for Golang applications where there is no such convenience.

References

  1. What is Application Insights;
  2. Exploring Metrics in Application Insights;
  3. In Golang, how to convert an error to a string?
  4. [Stack Overflow] How to get URL in http.Request?
  5. [Stack Overflow] How to get request string and method?
  6. [Stack Overflow] Golang http handler – time taken for request;
  7. [golang.org] func Split;
  8. Find the Length of an Array/Slice;
  9. [GitHub] Microsoft Application Insights SDK for Go;
  10. Golang 1.6: 使用mime.TypeByExtension来设置Content-Type;
  11. [Stack Overflow] What to use? http.ServeFile(..) or http.FileServer(..)?
  12. [Stack Overflow] How do you serve a static html file using a go web server?